Case study: supporting a digitally excluded customer after a payment scam
How a payments and commercial insurance intermediary moved a distressed APP scam victim off portal-only workflows and stopped repeat fraud.

Wiping a smartphone on police advice removes malicious remote-access software immediately, yet for a customer with low digital confidence it also slams shut the door on modern online banking, email, and self-service claim portals. That exact dilemma hit a 72-year-old sole trader who contacted a small UK payments and commercial insurance intermediary after losing £14,800 to an authorised push payment (APP) bank impersonation scam.
Every step of the firm's standard fraud-reimbursement and linked business cyber-insurance journey assumed comfortable smartphone use: logging into an encrypted online portal, resetting multi-factor authentication, scanning and uploading three months of PDF bank statements, and signing declarations electronically. After four failed password resets and an automated lockout message, the sole trader telephoned the general helpdesk audibly shaking and ready to abandon both his payment reimbursement request and his related commercial policy claim.
A senior case handler recognised at once how digital exclusion (capability) was colliding with recent financial shock (life events and resilience) to block access to fair redress. Slowing the conversation down, she thanked him for ringing in, reassured him plainly that portal problems would never forfeit his claim, and explained calmly that the firm could handle both the payment dispute and insurance notification entirely offline. Before logging his digital barriers and recent scam experience on file, she obtained clear verbal explicit consent and verified his identity using offline security checks.
Switching channels happened the same afternoon without fees or delay. The handler removed his account from automated portal-reminder emails, dispatched printed reimbursement and claim forms by tracked first-class post complete with prepaid return envelopes, and booked a fixed Wednesday 11am callback slot with herself as his single named contact. During that scheduled call, she read every section aloud in plain English and filled out administrative details carefully so he only needed to verify accuracy and post back paper bank statements.
Behind the scenes, coordinating two overlapping UK regulatory regimes prevented the customer from falling between stools. Under the Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) APP scam reimbursement framework, strict five-business-day assessment timelines apply unless stop-the-clock evidence gathering is justified, and the consumer standard of caution exception cannot be applied where vulnerability materially impaired the customer's ability to protect themselves. Simultaneously, the commercial cyber policy required prompt, fair claims handling under ICOBS 8 without penalising an insured sole trader for postal delays outside his control. By coordinating both tracks through one named handler, the firm kept statutory deadlines intact while printed statements travelled by post, rather than bouncing a stressed client between separate departments.
Protecting the customer from repeat harm was treated as a core Consumer Duty priority rather than an afterthought. Fraudsters routinely re-target recent APP scam victims within two to four weeks posing as bank investigators, FCA officers, or fee-charging recovery specialists. With the customer's agreement, the handler set clear, memorable rules on how the firm would contact him, agreed a personal verbal passphrase for every scheduled Wednesday call, and placed a temporary manual telephone verification check on any unusual outbound payment instructions.
Practical signposting rounded out the human support without blurring professional roles. Alongside printed copies of his claim timetable, the firm enclosed simple contact details for Action Fraud, Victim Support, and Citizens Advice so he had free, independent guidance on securing his replacement mobile phone and household accounts at his own pace rather than rushing back onto unfamiliar apps.
Within three weeks, the sole trader had submitted all paper evidence accurately, recovered the eligible reimbursement sum under the APP rules, and concluded his linked policy claim without further financial loss or secondary scam attempts. Equally helpful for oversight, clear file notes documented his explicit consent, the offline channel adjustments delivered, the vulnerability assessment shared in his reimbursement submission, and the anti-recovery-fraud safeguards agreed. During quarterly file sampling, the compliance lead also verified that every promised prepaid postal pack had left the office on time and that no automated portal reminder slipped through during the claim window.
Rather than treating the file as a one-off favour, the compliance lead brought the anonymised case to the firm's monthly Consumer Duty monitoring meeting. Recognising that hidden digital drop-offs probably affected other customers who never called the helpdesk, the firm added a bold, penalty-free banner across every portal login and document-upload screen ("Struggling with this online form? Call our UK team directly on our standard landline to handle everything by phone and post") and logged both the case and the permanent journey fix in its annual PRIN 2A.8 board report. Helpdesk advisers also completed a short refresher confirming how to dispatch prepaid postal packs on the same day without waiting for manager sign-off.
Practical answers for UK regulated firms
1Why do recent APP scam victims require extra safeguarding against repeat targeting?
Organised fraud groups frequently re-contact recent victims posing as recovery agents, police officers, or regulators. Clear contact rules, verbal passphrases, and proportionate callback checks on unusual instructions help prevent secondary losses.
2Is a portal-only claims or reimbursement journey compliant with Consumer Duty?
Digital-first journeys are acceptable for customers who use them easily, provided firms offer a prominent, penalty-free human alternative by telephone or post whenever capability, health, or access barriers arise.
3Does customer vulnerability affect assessments under the UK PSR APP scam reimbursement rules?
Yes. Under the PSR mandatory reimbursement framework, the consumer standard of caution exception does not apply where a customer's vulnerability had a material impact on their ability to protect themselves from the scam.
4Can a firm apply extra payment verification checks without the customer's agreement?
Standard fraud controls apply across all accounts, while bespoke ongoing account friction or special vulnerability adjustments should be explained clearly and agreed transparently with the customer wherever safe to do so.
5How should smaller payments or insurance firms spot digitally excluded customers who never ring in?
Monitor repeated password lockouts, abandoned document-upload screens, and incomplete claim forms during monthly checks, and place a prominent telephone fallback banner directly on high-friction web pages.
